Scribed by Sandre the Giant
Top of the list is one of the most unsettling albums of the year, and that’s just the cover art!
2023 has been one of the most challenging years of the blog’s existence, as we went full bore on a new massive anniversary series project, and it became the most incredible time sink. Yet unbelievably rewarding, because it gave us all new context for everything happening this year in extreme music. And what a year it was, making my top 20 incredibly difficult to organise, let alone the top 10. It has to be said that, if you were reviewed on this blog by me this year, I really liked your stuff. A lot. I don’t review things that I don’t like, there’s not enough time in this world for that. So, commiserations to you, and onto the final list.
Honourable mentions: literally all of you, you were all so good this year. Congratulations and I hope you sell shit loads of records.
20. Cruel Force – Dawn of the Axe: Pushing their music into more of a classic speed metal sound, while still keeping some of that blackened edge, Cruel Force are finding themselves as contributors to the rebirth of European thrash, rather than merely hangers on. ‘Dawn of the Axe’ is a record that gives us speed, riffs, hooks and enough Teutonic speed to satisfy even the most diehard, patchvest wearing mullethead. I’m talking about me, because I fucking love this record.
19. Mesmur – Chthonic: A staggering work of heaviness and grim doom, and as ‘Chthonic (Coda)’ brings us to a drifting, atmospheric end, we all have to raise praising hands to the sky for Mesmur. ‘Chthonic’ is a record of huge riffs, huge atmosphere and weeping funeral doom that is all you’ll need if you’re a fan of the genre.
18. VHS – Quest for the Mighty Riff: Remember when Municipal Waste reinvigorated thrash by being fun AND fucking great? Well, VHS could do that for death metal with ‘Quest for the Mighty Riff’. It’s Conan meets Golden Axe via Cannibal Corpse and At the Gates. Oh and by the way, their quest was definitely successful, for many mighty riffs are found within.
17. Rannoch – Conflagrations: The dynamics are incredible, the melancholic clean sections are glorious in their execution while the death metal is frenzied, fearsome and interwoven just perfectly. Rannoch have nailed it on this one, and this is definitely in the running for one of my favourite death metal releases this year. Stunning achievement!
16. Tetragrammacide – Typho-Tantric Aphorisms from the Arachneophidian Qur’an: Tetragrammacide are creating music that sounds like it’s barely hanging onto reality, a maelstorm of churning blackness and deathly power standing on your periphery, ready to suck you out into the abyss when you drop your guard. ‘Typho-Tantric Aphorisms from the Arachneophidian Qur’an’ is one of the year’s most serpentine and interesting death metal releases.
15. Dyspläcer – Temple Heights: ‘Temple Heights’ is a record that, despite its run time, never slows down or falls short of simply sublime It’s definitely one of the records I’ve revisited most this year. You’d have to be a miserable corpse painted prick to not have those horns in the air and your head banging. Thoroughly recommended
14. Frozen Dawn – The Decline of the Enlightened Gods: Remember that feeling you used to get when Behemoth kicked anything into gear around ‘Evangelion’? That’s what I get here, Frozen Dawn have grasped that tour de force and moulded it to their own particular melodic streak, which loses nothing in fury but gains exponentially in scope. ‘The Decline of the Enlightened Gods’ is an album that feels vitally alive and vibrant with black metal, which is a rarity in the genre at times. Dynamic, visceral and ferociously memorable, Frozen Dawn’s work has reached a crescendo right here, and it is thrilling.
13. Obituary – Dying of Everything: At the end of the day though, trying to fill a full review with variants of ‘It sounds like fucking Obituary so therefore it fucking kills and you should buy it’ is not as easy as you’d think but it is the honest truth. Turns out that death metal legends are really hard to keep down these days, and with Autopsy crushing 2022 and Obituary starting 2023 like this, who can possibly stop them?
12. Sarcoptes – Prayers to Oblivion: The songwriting is insidiously memorable, the tones of guitar and bass are excellent and the drumming performance is massive. Add just the right amount of keyboard dashes when required and you’ve got the kind of vast, powerful black metal I’ve been waiting for. ‘Prayers to Oblivion’ is classic black metal done with modern production values and it sounds incredible.
11. Sorrowful Land – Faded Anchors of the Past: Death/doom today seems to suffer from a quagmire of sameyness; bands repeating the same slow riffs, bleak melody lines and massive growls without putting any real heart into it. Sorrowful Land do not have that issue; each song drips with a genuine heartache and cold grasping sadness. You cannot help but wonder if what is going on in his homeland has given new weight to Max’s compositions here, adding poignancy to an already weeping monolith of crushing moroseness. Whatever it is, ‘Faded Anchors of the Past’ is a record coloured richly in shades of grey where both misery and hope lie entwined in a fatal embrace.
10. Coffin Mulch – Spectral Intercession: Coffin Mulch have found a place to thrive, locked in between old school Autopsy worship and something a little more uncomfortable, a little more dense and doomy that breeds such swampy brutality. That welded to a penchant for classic Swedeath guitar tone and riffs gives you a record that is genuinely recognisable as their own, which is difficult to claim at this point in death metal. This is a real contender for 2023’s best death metal record
9. Iravu – A Fate Worse Than Home: ‘A Fate Worse Than Home’ is the Wolves in the Throne Room-meets-2001: A Space Odyssey soundtrack mash up I didn’t know I needed in my life. An ambient influenced record that isn’t just dropping in random synth parts but having it as the underlying body of the music, a thick bed where the roots of atmospheric black metal can grow and flourish into black, flowering beauty
8. The Salt Pale Collective – A Body That Could Pass Through Stones and Trees: It feels like it is two beasts; a primal riff led brutality and a sleek, ethereal soundscape both possessing the same body. ‘A Body That Could Pass Through Stones and Trees’ is the sound of a band combining those two disparate elements with ease, and becoming a potential future of British doom
7. Tribunal – The Weight of Remembrance: As the crumbling edifice of ‘The Path’ snakes its way through mournful atmosphere, weeping riffs and morose melodies to a titanic conclusion, I can safely say that ‘The Weight of Remembrance’ had cemented its place at the top of my albums of 2023 by January, and only a few records managed to top the generational talent sweeping across death, doom and gothic splendour that is Tribunal. A masterpiece of emotive, haunting gothic doom
6. Helms Deep – Treacherous Ways: ‘Treacherous Ways’ is an absolute instant classic, giving you all the old school metal you could ever want. A heady mix of Agent Steel, Iron Maiden, Night Demon and Satan, given an injection of modern enthusiasm and thrust, means that Helms Deep are now absolute must listen material. This is amazing.
5. Tomb Mold – The Enduring Spirit: ‘The Enduring Spirit’ is a record set to blow those pretenders away and re-establish their place as kings of the genre. Tomb Mold didn’t forget about why old death metal bands are so revered; they didn’t bring repetitive riffs and growls, they created something vitally alive and interesting, as well as brutally heavy. That is the true legacy of those bands and only a rare band like Tomb Mold has the audacity to take that mantle into strange new worlds like this. Old school progressive death metal? Thank fuck for that then!
4. Impalement – The Dawn of Blackened Death: Impalement were always on my radar after their debut, but this is a whole new world for them. A stunningly atmospheric and furious work of majestic darkness. ‘The Dawn of Blackened Death’ is coming for us all.
3. Hellripper – Warlocks Grim and Withered Hags: Hellripper have always lived up to their name; tearing the nastiest of riffs from the bowels of Satan’s home and then rippping killer solos over the top to the chagrin of all who would challenge. But the new direction that this album suggests is a very interesting proposition. I genuinely thought Hellripper would struggle to top ‘Affair of the Poisons’, but clearly I was wrong. ‘Warlocks Grim and Withered Hags’ is a whole new level for Hellripper, taking the burning old school attack and forging a new, more potent weapon from the flames
2. Nine Altars – The Eternal Penance: This is proper doom; a rich tapestry of soulful blues riffs soaked in a morose melancholy and given voice with full, powerful vocals. It reminds me a lot of Twilight of the Gods, and their 2013 release ‘Fire on the Mountain’. That was ‘proper metal’, brought back to the fore in a big way and given a place again This is what ‘The Eternal Penance’ is, an album that feels out of time and yet still stunningly comtemporary because, let’s face it, metal like this is fucking forever. I love this record
1. Dwelling Below – Dwelling Below: A horrendous slab of the ugliest, most awe-inspiringly uncomfortable death/doom you may ever hear, ‘Dwelling Below’ is a record that thrives on a sense of unease, on which it builds slow motion devastation and dark, morbid atmospheres. There’s death/doom that is positively sepulchral in tone, and then there is this, which feels like the sepulchre exists beyond time and space, somewhere out there in the dark where the spawn of unspeakable things are ready to follow you back to our world.