Scribed by Sandre the Giant
It would seem that 2004 was a bit of a comeback year for some bands; we’ve just seen the re-emergence of Death Angel and now brutal death metal titans and kings of New York death metal Suffocation were to return after 6 years to give us ‘Souls to Deny’. They hadn’t been together since 1998’s ‘Despise the Sun’ EP, and it was another sign that perhaps 2004 was the year where extremity returned to metal after its chart flirtations. But Suffocation are a band who were genre definers, sub genre creators and all round legends of death metal, would their oldest of old school approach to brutality still feel important in 2004, or was it going to be a struggle to recover their position?
Of course it wasn’t a fucking issue. ‘Souls to Deny’ is an album that you instantly recognise as Suffocation, that tight brutality and technicality was their trademark and now was their siren song back to our world. The guitar work is an intricate and crushing as always, executed with the kind of “how are they doing that” style Suffocation have always given us. I mean seriously, how do you sound this monolithic and still impress with technical skills? There have been brutal death metal bands who have tried for decades to match that peerless Frank Mullen guttural and no one makes it sound just as good. ‘Souls to Deny’ is a frantic record, a frenzied riddle of blastbeats, stop start riffing, crushing low end brutality and razor sharp lead guitar work. ‘Surgery of Impalement’ became an instant DM classic on release, and I think one of the reasons that this record felt so right was that Suffocation hadn’t changed their sound or approach from their earliest material. They got their sound perfected on ‘Effigy of the Forgotten’, and then continued to refine it over the following records. It meant that they could pretty much just pick up where they left off in 1998 and still be as revered.
Frank Mullen may have retired by 2024, but albums like this just reassert his position as one of the kings of death metal vocals, and Suffocation have continued to rip album after album of ludicrous quality over the intervening years. Death metal was marching back to the fore in 2004, coming for those innocent little maggots who had gotten the merest sliver of it in Slipknot and thought, fuck this heavy heavy shit is for me. I was one of these kids. Well, you’ve been given a number of great records in death metal in 2004 already, and ‘Souls to Deny’ is, ahem, undeniably one of the 2000s best death metal records.
https://www.facebook.com/suffocation